Of God we ask one favor — Pagan

Of God we ask one favor, 1
That we may be forgiven-
For what, he is presumed to know-
The Crime, from us, is hidden-
Immured the whole of Life 5
Within a magic Prison
We reprimand the Happiness
That too competes with Heaven.
(F.1675/J.1601)
[1, 2] God, favor, forgiven:: Dickinson was not seriously asked for forgiveness, but stated a fact.
[4, 5] Crime, Life:: the whole of life is sealed in our own heaven, and its happiness is better than God's heaven.
[6] magic Prison:: a heaven in earth that can compete with God's.
[7] We reprimand:: we have experienced the happiness already, so that we can reprimand it.
[8] too competes with Heaven:: Dickinson believed not the story of Heaven.